Francois Thoral

Wellington, Aotearoa - New Zealand·
francoisthoral@gmail.com - Francois.Thoral@niwa.co.nz
ORCID iD icon0000-0003-0457-1735

Kia ora, ko Francois tōku ingoa! I am a postdoctoral fellow between the Univeristy of Waikato and the National Institute of Water and Atmospheric Research (NIWA), I am currently based in Wellington, New Zealand. Within the Tau Ki Ākau - Ridge to Reef - research project, my research investigates the availability of light reaching the seabed for coastal ecosystems around Aotearoa New Zealand, and in a multi-stressor context, such as changes in water clarity and increasing marine heatwaves. To pursue it, I combine satellite remote sensing, optical modelling of underwater light and algal physiology. Broadly speaking, I am interested in bridging theoretical and applied ecology. Previously, I was a PhD Student at the University of Canterbury (UC) in Christchurch, New Zealand.

Thesis Project in Video

Sometimes a quick video is better than a long text. So check the video I have made for the 2020 Visualise Your Thesis competition in the local heat of my University.

Thesis Project in a few words

More precisely in my project, I am investigating the availability of light for coastal ecosystems overall New Zealand, especially underwater forests. I am making use of the remote sensing of light via satellites and drones as well as optical modelling and in-situ measurements. The knowledge gained from these new technologies helps me developping methods to efficiently monitor the light environment around the coasts.

I am furthermore interested in how a change in the light environment drives valuable communities to shift towards alternative ones. The reason is that these shifts are usually accompanied with a loss of services that the previous state of the ecosystem was providing us. Long story short, this is about understanding what we can potential loose by continuing changing our marine environment and more importantly, what can we do to protect what we benefit from.

As an example, there are amazing and very valuable underwater forests around New Zealand. These forests are mainly dominated by kelp species, which are macroalgae that can grow BIG depending on the species. Associated with these underwater forests are many other species, some of economical interest such as the rock lobster or the pāua, the local abalone. Unfortunately and so are the forests in land, the kelp forests are locally and globally declining due to different factors including marine heat waves, storms and waves or sedimentation. The goal of my study is to investigate how a change of the light availability at the bottom of the sea is influencing the valuable underwater forests.

So a big part of my project is to use satellite data to estimate the amounf of light reaching the seabed or seafloor. This is important as the light reaching the bottom of the sea will then be available for underwater forests. The good thing about using satellite data is that they have been collecting data for a few decades now (depending on the satellite itself), so we can have an idea if there has been more or less light for the underwater forests these past decades. We can also investigate why.

The gifs below show of the average daily light reaching the seabed for every months, estimated by satellite and for the North and South Island of New Zealand. The blue/purple colours mean almost no light whereas the green/yellow/red colours mean potentially enough light to sustain photosynthesis and productive underwater forests.

xx. The data are derived from the satellite Aqua (MODIS).
Anomalies of the amount of light reaching the bottom of the sea around the North Island of New Zealand. The data are derived from the satellite Aqua (MODIS).

One apparent feature is the extension and retraction of the illuminated seabed, pulsing throughout the seasons. There is obviously more light reaching the seabed durign Summer than Winter. We can also see from the maps above that there is quite a bit of change in space and time of the amount of light reaching the seabed apart from the seasonal aspect. A goal of the thesis is to explore what is causing this variability.


Publications

Long-term warming and record-breaking marine heatwaves in the Hauraki Gulf, northern New Zealand New Zealand Journal of Marine and Freshwater Research

Nick T Shears, Melissa O Bowen, François Thoral
Marine heatwaves (MHWs) have increased worldwide in intensity, frequency, and duration, often with severe impacts on ecologically and socio-economically important coastal habitats. Most MHW studies have focused on summer events in specific regions or global open-water analyses with little consideration to seasonality or spatial biogeography of the nearshore zone. We address this research gap by analysing changes to MHWs across seasons and ecoregions, within 12 nautical miles (NM) of New Zealand’s coastline, an area with high biodiversity and endemism. We used season-specific linear trend analysis with temporal breakpoints between 1982 and 2021 to identify the number of MHW events and MHW days, and mean, maximum, and cumulative intensity of MHWs for New Zealand coastal ecoregions. Across ecoregions, 69.5% of 200 trend analyses increased significantly whereas the remaining 30.5% were unaffected. For the significant increases, temporal breakpoints occurred between 1994 and 2012. We conclude that MHWs have become stronger, longer and more frequent across coastal New Zealand, but with some variability within and between regions. Our trend-analyses could enable retrospective analyses of biological tipping-points and inform management practices that may enhance the resilience of ecoregions yet to face MHW breakpoints or those in the initial stages of major climatic changes.
June 2023

Seasonal trends in marine heatwaves highlight vulnerable coastal ecoregions and historic change points in New Zealand New Zealand Journal of Marine and Freshwater Research

Shinae Montie, François Thoral , Robert O Smith, Felix Cook, Leigh W Tait, Matthew H Pinkerton, David R Schiel, Mads S Thomsen
Marine heatwaves (MHWs) have increased worldwide in intensity, frequency, and duration, often with severe impacts on ecologically and socio-economically important coastal habitats. Most MHW studies have focused on summer events in specific regions or global open-water analyses with little consideration to seasonality or spatial biogeography of the nearshore zone. We address this research gap by analysing changes to MHWs across seasons and ecoregions, within 12 nautical miles (NM) of New Zealand’s coastline, an area with high biodiversity and endemism. We used season-specific linear trend analysis with temporal breakpoints between 1982 and 2021 to identify the number of MHW events and MHW days, and mean, maximum, and cumulative intensity of MHWs for New Zealand coastal ecoregions. Across ecoregions, 69.5% of 200 trend analyses increased significantly whereas the remaining 30.5% were unaffected. For the significant increases, temporal breakpoints occurred between 1994 and 2012. We conclude that MHWs have become stronger, longer and more frequent across coastal New Zealand, but with some variability within and between regions. Our trend-analyses could enable retrospective analyses of biological tipping-points and inform management practices that may enhance the resilience of ecoregions yet to face MHW breakpoints or those in the initial stages of major climatic changes.
June 2023

Spectral light quality on the seabed matters for macroalgal community composition at the extremities of light limitation Limnology & Oceanography

François Thoral , Matthew H Pinkerton, Leigh W Tait, David R Schiel
Compromised light quantity on the seabed affects the composition and resilience of marine forests and the maintenance of ecosystem services. However, the response of macroalgal assemblages to changes in the quality (spectral composition) of light as compared to the quantity alone is poorly understood. Here, we bridge radiative transfer modeling and algal physiology to simulate the underwater light environment and explore macroalgal responses to spectral attenuation by various coastal water constituents. We considered three groups of macroalgal taxa (class Phaeophyceae and, phyla Chlorophyta and Rhodophyta) for which we developed a “synthetic envelope” of spectrally resolved action spectra using 1 million radiative simulations. We found that brown algae were more efficient at harvesting light across the whole spectrum at low attenuation (< 0.2 m−1) when depths were greater than 10 m, whereas green algae dominated shallower depths than 10 m for low to high attenuation values. Finally, red algae made best use of the available light at relatively higher attenuation values (> 0.2 m−1) and deeper depths. We also demonstrated that the brown and green algal taxa showed higher photosynthetic efficiencies when attenuation was dominated by particulate matter rather than by phytoplankton or detrital matter. Our results shed new light on the “Complementary Chromatic Adaptation” hypothesis by confirming that algal pigmentation matters under a subset of scenarios, particularly at the limits of light availability in coastal waters. This study paves the way for identifying competitive thresholds in macroalgal communities by using satellite-derived ocean color products to identify regions and depths of potential optical transitions.
February 2023

Check out the interactive app I made for everyone to explore the dataset:

Horizon Scan on the Benefits of Ocean Seasonal Forecasting in a Future of Increasing Marine Heatwaves for Aotearoa New Zealand Frontiers in Climate

Craig L Stevens, Claire M Spillman, Erik Behrens, Niall Broekhuizen, Paula Holland, Yvonne Matthews, Ben Noll, Joanne M O'Callaghan, Neelesh Rampal, Robert O Smith, Iman Soltanzadeh, Leight W Tait, David I Taylor, François Thoral , Erica Williams
With climate heating, Aotearoa New Zealand is expected to experience more marine heatwaves (MHW) in the coming decades. These extreme events are already impacting the island nation's marine and coastal environments and marine industries at a variety of scales. There will potentially be substantial benefits in developing an early warning system–specifically ocean seasonal forecast tools. This near-term 2,030 horizon scan reviews studies supporting the development of this capability and notes work needed to enable stakeholders to benefit from this knowledge. Review findings congregate around six themes; (1) MHW impacts, (2) mechanistic understanding, (3) observational basis, (4) seasonal forecast tools, (5) supporting Te Tiriti (The Treaty of Waitangi) and Māori aspirations, and (6) end-user engagement. The primary recommendation is a cross-institutional, cross-sector MHW Taskforce that would address, in a coordinated and effective fashion, the real, multi-faceted challenges associated with the committed pathway of warming. A range of sub-recommendations follow that connect with the United Nations Ocean Decade initiative.
June 2022

Unravelling seasonal trends in coastal marine heatwave metrics across global biogeographical realms Scientific Reports

François Thoral , Shinae Montie, Mads S Thomsen, Leigh W Tait, Matthew H Pinkerton, David R Schiel
Marine heatwaves (MHWs) can cause dramatic changes to ecologically, culturally, and economically important coastal ecosystems. To date, MHW studies have focused on geographically isolated regions or broad-scale global oceanic analyses, without considering coastal biogeographical regions and seasons. However, to understand impacts from MHWs on diverse coastal communities, a combined biogeographical-seasonal approach is necessary, because (1) bioregions reflect community-wide temperature tolerances and (2) summer or winter heatwaves likely affect communities differently. We therefore carried out season-specific Theil–Sen robust linear regressions and Pettitt change point analyses from 1982 to 2021 on the number of events, number of MHW days, mean intensity, maximum intensity, and cumulative intensity of MHWs, for each of the world’s 12 major coastal biogeographical realms. We found that 70% of 240 trend analyses increased significantly, 5% decreased and 25% were unaffected. There were clear differences between trends in metrics within biogeographical regions, and among seasons. For the significant increases, most change points occurred between 1998 and 2006. Regression slopes were generally positive across MHW metrics, seasons, and biogeographical realms as well as being highest after change point detection. Trends were highest for the Arctic, Northern Pacific, and Northern Atlantic realms in summer, and lowest for the Southern Ocean and several equatorial realms in other seasons. Our analysis highlights that future case studies should incorporate break point changes and seasonality in MHW analysis, to increase our understanding of how future, more frequent, and stronger MHWs will affect coastal ecosystems.
May 2022

Check out the interactive app I made for everyone to explore the dataset:

Cascading impacts of earthquakes and extreme heatwaves have destroyed populations of an iconic marine foundation species Diversity and Distribution

Mads S Thomsen, Luca Mondardini, François Thoral , Derek Gerber, Shinae Montie, Paul M South, Leigh Tait, Shane Orchard, Tommaso Alestra, David R Schiel
Ecologists traditionally study how contemporary local processes, such as biological interactions and physical stressors, affect the distribution and abundance of organisms. By comparison, biogeographers study the distribution of the same organisms, but focus on historic, larger-scale processes that can cause mass mortalities, such as earthquakes. Here we document cascading effects of rare biogeographical (seismic) and more common ecological (temperature-related) processes on the distribution and abundances of coastal foundation species. Intertidal wave-exposed rocky reefs around Kaikōura, New Zealand, dominated by large, long-lived, and iconic southern bull kelps (Durvillaea antarctica and Durvillaea willana ). In November 2016, a 7.8 Mw earthquake uplifted the coastline around Kaikōura by up to 2 m, and a year later the region experienced the hottest summer on record. Extensive sampling of intertidal communities over 15 km coastline were done shortly after the earthquake and heatwaves and 4 years after the earthquake. Durvillaea lost 75% of its canopy to uplift and the heatwaves reduced canopies that had survived the uplift by an additional 35%. The survey done 4 years after the earthquake showed that Durvillaea had not recovered and that the intertidal zone in many places now was dominated by small turfs and foliose seaweed. Cascading impacts from seismic uplift and heatwaves have destroyed populations of Durvillaea around Kaikōura. Surviving smaller and sparser Durvillaea patches will likely compromise capacity for self-replacement and lower resilience to future stressors. These results are discussed in a global biogeographical-ecological context of seismic activity and extreme heatwaves and highlight that these events, which are not particularly rare in a geological context, may have common long-lasting ecological legacies.
September 2021

Loss of giant kelp, Macrocystis pyrifera, driven by marine heatwaves and exacerbated by poor water clarity in New Zealand Frontiers in Marine Science

Leigh W Tait, François Thoral , MH Pinkerton, Mads S Thomsen, David R Schiel
Marine heatwaves (MHW) are becoming stronger and more frequent across the globe. MHWs affect the thermal physiology of all biological organisms, but wider ecosystem effects are particularly impactful when large habitat-forming foundation species such as kelps are affected. Many studies on impacts from MHWs on kelps have focused on temperature effects in isolation, except for a few studies that have integrated co-occurring stress from grazers, wave exposure and nutrient limitation. It is likely that many stressors act in concert with MHWs and exacerbate their effects. Here we analyzed satellite images over 60 months to assess temporal changes in abundance of surface canopies of the giant kelp Macrocystis pyrifera in the New Zealand coastal zone. The analysis encompassed the most extreme MHW on record (2017/18), across a 6° latitudinal gradient of four regions southward from the northern distributional limit of Macrocystis along mainland New Zealand. We tested the association of surface canopy cover of Macrocystis with sea surface temperature, temperature anomalies, chlorophyll-a (a proxy for nutrient availability) and water clarity (diffuse attenuation coefficient). We found a reduced cover of Macrocystis across all regions during and after the 2017/18 MHW, with least impact at the most southern region where the maximum temperatures did not exceed 18°C. There was also an important and significant interaction between temperature and water clarity, showing that temperature-induced kelp loss was greater when water clarity was poor. These results show that notable negative effects occurred across the coastal range of this foundation species and highlight the importance of studying MHW effects across latitudinal gradients and in concert with other co-occurring stressors.
August 2021

Talks and Events

Science is amazing and a passion of me. And talking about science is crucial. I try to do my best to share my research with different audience, from scientists to the the general public. Here is a collection of my past and incoming talks.

International Conference on Machine Intelligence for Geoanalytics and remote sensing - MIGARS

Wellington, Aotearoa New Zealand
Scientific Presentation: Connecting land-use, sediments, and ocean color remote sensing to safeguard Aotearoa New Zealand’s coastal ecosystems health leveraging Machine Learning?
8-10 April 2024

New Zealand Marine Science Society Conference - NZMSS

Theme: “Reconnecting… people and science - Te Herenga Waka The University of Wellington, Aotearoa New Zealand
Scientific Presentation: Connecting land-use, sediment flows and macroalgal productivity around Aotearoa New Zealand’s reefs
26-28 June 2023

International Temperate Reefs Symposium - ITRS

Hobart, Australia
Scientific Presentation: Variation in the spectral quality of seabed light and its effect on macroalgal communities
2nd Best Student Presentation Prize
8-12 January 2023

International Conference on Southern Hemisphere Meteorology and Oceanography - ICSHMO

Ōtautahi - Christchurch, Aotearoa New Zealand
Scientific Presentation: More or Less Light for Kelp Forests? Satellite-derived National Trends of Benthic Light and Macroalgal implications
8-12 February 2022

Annual Biology Conference - ABC

Ōtautahi - Christchurch, Aotearoa New Zealand
Scientific Presentation: More or Less Light for Kelp Forests? Satellite-derived National Trends of Benthic Light and Macroalgal implications - Book of abstracts
28 October 2021

New Zealand Marine Science Society Conference - NZMSS

Theme: “Titiro whakamuri, kōkiri whakamua” (looking back to move forward) - Tauranga Moana, Aotearoa New Zealand
Scientific Presentation: National Trends of Benthic Light Availability for Kelp Forests Using Satellite Imagery
5-8 July 2021

Marine Geological and Biological Habitat Mapping Conference - GeoHab

Asia and Pacific Node - Online Conference
Scientific Presentation: Estimating Benthic Light from Satellite and Implications for Kelp Forests
11 May 2021

Annual Biology Conference - ABC

Ōtautahi - Christchurch, Aotearoa New Zealand
Scientific Presentation: Estimating Benthic Light from Satellite and Implications for Kelp Forests - Book of abstracts
Session Chair Prize
22 October 2020

I am trying as much as I can to get involved in side projects that includes popularizing or using Science in Society. Here is a list of projects I have been fortunate to get involved into.

Ultrawild, An Audacious Plan to Rewild Every City on Earth - Steve Mushin

Written and illustrated by industrial designer, inventor and sustainability teacher Steve Mushin, Ultrawild was published by Allen and Unwin in October 2023.
Ultrawild is an illustrated science and design book about tackling climate change with hilarious engineering ideas and extreme rewilding known as ultrawilding. Ultrawild has been created in collaboration with experts ranging from climate scientists and marine biologists to mechanical engineers and soil scientists. I was very lucky to be one of them and work with Steve on some super crazy-inspiring ideas. You can find me in the book, I'll let you find where. Thanks again Steve!
2023

TakiWaehere NZ GeoSpatial Hackathon - TakiWaehere

National Event, NEW ZEALAND - NZ Space Agency - MBIE - MAXAR - NZ Universities
Project: Seaside Site SEALection
Our project is a coastal classification tool that automatically identifies appropriate seal habitat using very high resolution satellite imagery. The application displays an “attractiveness” score for each site on the image, which takes into consideration landscape features such as distance from cliffs and beach surface area, as well as historical presence/absence of seals at that site. The user will also add to the validity of the application by feeding in additional observation data, opening it to citizen science application.
17-18 April 2021

Awards and Honours

Always humbling to get rewarded.

International Temperate Reefs Symposium - ITRS

Hobart, Tasmania
2nd Best Student Presentation Prize
2023

Conference Travel Grant

School of Biological Sciences - University of Canterbury
Contestable fund.
2021

TakiWaehere NZ GeoSpatial Hackathon - TakiWaehere

National Event, NEW ZEALAND - NZ Space Agency - MBIE - MAXAR - NZ Universities
3rd Place at local Uni heat.
2021

Annual Biology Conference - ABC

University of Canterbury, NEW ZEALAND
Session Chair Prize
2020

Vizualise Your Thesis - Local University Heat

University of Canterbury
1-minute long video to explain my thesis topic. Entry Highly Commended.
2020

PhD Scholarship

University of Canterbury (UC) - National Institute of Water and Atmospheric Research (NIWA)
Join-Programme, 3-Year Scholarship.
2019-2022

M.Sc. Thesis Research Grant

Mediterranean Institute of Oceanography (MIO) - Aix-Marseille University
5-Month Scholarship.
2018

Education

PhD Student

University of Canterbury, NEW ZEALAND
Marine Ecology - How light is impacting valuable marine ecosystems - Use of Remote Sensing - Having fun in NZ
2019 - 2023

Masters of Oceanography - Marine Biology and Ecology specialty

Aix-Marseille University, FRANCE
Focus in Ecologial Modelling - Theoretical Ecology - Statistics - Nerdish but still on the outdoors
2015 - 2018

Bachelor of Science - Biogeochemical and Physical Oceanography specialty

Aix-Marseille University, FRANCE
Dynamics of the Ocean - Physical equations - Applied Mathematics - Growing interest in Ecology and Modelling
2012 - 2015

Skills

Programming Languages & Tools
Mathematical Modelling
Statistics
R Coding

Experience

RANGER

Calanques National Park, Marseille - France

Ranger during peak season in a french national park. Tasks included rasing awareness to the general public about ecological and cultural value of the park. Sensibilisation to risks. Observation and report of flora/fauna as well as usages in the park. Patrol on land and at sea.

June 2018 - July 2018

Masters Thesis

Aix-Marseille University - Mediterranean Institue of Oceanography

INCOMING.

January 2018 - July 2018

You seem curious, more to come ...

Before